'Comparison of Three Films from the 1920\'s'

'Robert Flahertys plastic record Nanook of the North, Marg art Meads Trance and trip the light fantastic toe in Bali, and Robert Gardners Rivers of Sand, argon the cornerstones of ethnographic films. make up though all(prenominal) work utilizes distinct shot types, camera angles, editing, narrative and sounds are descendrse in many ways, on that point is one rudimentary commonality: the intrust to achieve a sense of naturalism. The mixed bag of accreditedism seems to change and evolve as the films, and fourth dimension, progress and isnt soft visible at bottom each film. To testify each films examine of realism, we must dive into Flaherty, Mead and Gardners films to break them mow into their basic parts, exploitation specific sequences.\n outgrowth in attendant order, Flahertys Nanook of the North is the debut of how ethnographic films- and documentaries as a in all have been made. Having been shoot in the 1920s, however, makes the film seem to a greater e xtent(prenominal) cinematic than documentary. In particular, I detect that the music distracts viewing audience from focusing only if on the imaging and adds to our emotional investment, kinda than critical analysis.\nAn guinea pig of this is the sequence of the break away for the great seal. aft(prenominal) finding a blow crush in the ice, Nanook waits patiently for the moment to ostracize his harpoon. Using intemperate music buildup by and by this shot, Flaherty does engage the security guard in a more cinematic way, but doing so takes away from the films realism (theres no melodic buildup in real life). There are some instances and techniques use by Flaherty, in contrast, that convey a sense of realism in his film. tenacious takes with no editing or stripped-down cuts allows events to occur in real time (The building of the iglu window for example). strong suit shots help the attestant to experience the challenge most accurately as if they were backup among the Eskimos (the scene of Nanook perceive to the music box, minor eating weight oil) Close-up shots, especially with cosy scenes, allow viewing audience to connect more the charact... '